Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
Locked
 
|
Hi Guys,
I've asked about this before, and have had some information relating to timeouts, but the root cause is still a mystery to me, and it's a terrible user experience, so I think it might deserve some sort of investigation or escalation. I'm pretty patient, but I feel that anybody else might drop cloud foundry immediately and look elsewhere, and that's not what I want, because it's an otherwise great service/integration. When I use the grails cf-update command from the cloud-foundry plugin, it virtually never succeeds first time, and in fact fails with simply 'Error: null'. I usually have to re-run it up to 15 times, which can take maybe half an hour of manual work. I'm trying to prepare my environment for a client meeting and I'm getting hugely frustrated. My environment is Ubuntu 11.10, Grails 2.0.4, Cloud-foundry 1.2.2 and cloud-support 1.0.11 Tonight, this has been my last 1.5 hours: ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811029078.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811110194.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811220629.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811961870.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812047321.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812589878.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files.... | Compiling 2 source files.... | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812972916.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342813047533.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819416649.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819559469.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819940018.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: Error: null ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update | Compiling 2 source files. Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342820682847.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: ... Any ideas what I can do to resolve this situation? -- ________________________________ ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
|
No experience with CF, but you could write a shell script to re-run
the command until it succeeds, or simply `grails prod cf-update || grails prod cf-update || etc.` On 21 July 2012 00:55, Antony Jones <[hidden email]> wrote: > Hi Guys, > > I've asked about this before, and have had some information relating > to timeouts, but the root cause is still a mystery to me, and it's a > terrible user experience, so I think it might deserve some sort of > investigation or escalation. I'm pretty patient, but I feel that > anybody else might drop cloud foundry immediately and look elsewhere, > and that's not what I want, because it's an otherwise great > service/integration. > When I use the grails cf-update command from the cloud-foundry plugin, > it virtually never succeeds first time, and in fact fails with simply > 'Error: null'. I usually have to re-run it up to 15 times, which can > take maybe half an hour of manual work. I'm trying to prepare my > environment for a client meeting and I'm getting hugely frustrated. > > My environment is Ubuntu 11.10, Grails 2.0.4, Cloud-foundry 1.2.2 and > cloud-support 1.0.11 > > Tonight, this has been my last 1.5 hours: > > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811029078.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811110194.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811220629.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811961870.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812047321.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812589878.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files.... > | Compiling 2 source files.... > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812972916.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342813047533.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819416649.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819559469.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819940018.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > Error: null > ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update > | Compiling 2 source files. > Building war file > | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342820682847.war > > Updating Application: > Checking for available resources: > > > ... > > Any ideas what I can do to resolve this situation? > > -- > ________________________________ > ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: > > http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
Yeah I've done that, but that doesn't address the root cause. I'm not
the only one who has this problem, and it's a real deal-breaker for most of those people. Cheers for the help though, Antony On 21 July 2012 13:09, Alex Anderson <[hidden email]> wrote: > No experience with CF, but you could write a shell script to re-run > the command until it succeeds, or simply `grails prod cf-update || > grails prod cf-update || etc.` > > On 21 July 2012 00:55, Antony Jones <[hidden email]> wrote: >> Hi Guys, >> >> I've asked about this before, and have had some information relating >> to timeouts, but the root cause is still a mystery to me, and it's a >> terrible user experience, so I think it might deserve some sort of >> investigation or escalation. I'm pretty patient, but I feel that >> anybody else might drop cloud foundry immediately and look elsewhere, >> and that's not what I want, because it's an otherwise great >> service/integration. >> When I use the grails cf-update command from the cloud-foundry plugin, >> it virtually never succeeds first time, and in fact fails with simply >> 'Error: null'. I usually have to re-run it up to 15 times, which can >> take maybe half an hour of manual work. I'm trying to prepare my >> environment for a client meeting and I'm getting hugely frustrated. >> >> My environment is Ubuntu 11.10, Grails 2.0.4, Cloud-foundry 1.2.2 and >> cloud-support 1.0.11 >> >> Tonight, this has been my last 1.5 hours: >> >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811029078.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811110194.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811220629.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811961870.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812047321.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812589878.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files.... >> | Compiling 2 source files.... >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812972916.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342813047533.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819416649.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819559469.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819940018.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342820682847.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> >> ... >> >> Any ideas what I can do to resolve this situation? >> >> -- >> ________________________________ >> ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org >> >> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: >> >> http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email >> >> > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: > > http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email > > -- ________________________________ ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
In reply to this post by antony
Hey antony, I agree re-running does not help too much for finding the root cause. Try printing the error stack trace out for more info and get back here (or just go to the cf support page, http://support.cloudfoundry.com/, to submit the issue). To do that, add this line to your-app/conf/Config.groovy:
grails.plugin.cloudfoundry.showStackTrace=true It would be a good idea to come with more details of your app if you still get troubled. These commands would be always useful: grails cf-services grails cf-info grails cf-apps |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
In reply to this post by antony
I've seen this previously but can't get it to fail now. Could you add some logging config and post (or email me directly) the output:
trace 'grails.plugin.cloudfoundry' trace 'grails.plugin.cloudsupport' This will be fairly verbose since it will log all of the JSON responses. Burt
|
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
|
Hi Burt,
Will do this for you asap. Cheers, Antony On 27 July 2012 02:10, burtbeckwith <[hidden email]> wrote: > I've seen this previously but can't get it to fail now. Could you add some > logging config and post (or email me directly) the output: > > trace 'grails.plugin.cloudfoundry' > trace 'grails.plugin.cloudsupport' > > This will be fairly verbose since it will log all of the JSON responses. > > Burt > > > antony wrote >> >> Hi Guys, >> >> I've asked about this before, and have had some information relating >> to timeouts, but the root cause is still a mystery to me, and it's a >> terrible user experience, so I think it might deserve some sort of >> investigation or escalation. I'm pretty patient, but I feel that >> anybody else might drop cloud foundry immediately and look elsewhere, >> and that's not what I want, because it's an otherwise great >> service/integration. >> When I use the grails cf-update command from the cloud-foundry plugin, >> it virtually never succeeds first time, and in fact fails with simply >> 'Error: null'. I usually have to re-run it up to 15 times, which can >> take maybe half an hour of manual work. I'm trying to prepare my >> environment for a client meeting and I'm getting hugely frustrated. >> >> My environment is Ubuntu 11.10, Grails 2.0.4, Cloud-foundry 1.2.2 and >> cloud-support 1.0.11 >> >> Tonight, this has been my last 1.5 hours: >> >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811029078.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811110194.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811220629.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342811961870.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812047321.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812589878.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files.... >> | Compiling 2 source files.... >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342812972916.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342813047533.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819416649.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819559469.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342819940018.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> Error: null >> ant@bronx:~/Projects/my-application$ grails prod cf-update >> | Compiling 2 source files. >> Building war file >> | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1342820682847.war >> >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> >> >> ... >> >> Any ideas what I can do to resolve this situation? >> >> -- >> ________________________________ >> ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org >> >> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: >> >> http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email >> > > > > > -- > View this message in context: http://grails.1312388.n4.nabble.com/Deploying-to-cloud-foundry-is-still-a-miserable-experience-tp4631977p4632321.html > Sent from the Grails - user mailing list archive at Nabble.com. > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: > > http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email > > -- ________________________________ ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
|
In reply to this post by burtbeckwith
Hi Burt, List,
As requested. It's not as verbose as perhaps you might have liked. I've replaced sensitive information. ant@bronx:~/Projects/snip$ grails -Dgrails.env=cloudfoundry cf-update | Compiling 3 source files. 2012-08-01 17:40:58,000 [main] TRACE cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - Invoking client method login with args [] 2012-08-01 17:40:59,186 [main] DEBUG cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - Last Request: {"token":"bearer eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJleHAiOjEzNDQxOTkwODMsInVzZXJfbmFtZSI6ImFkam9uZXMrY2xsnipWlsLmNvbSIsInNjb3BlIjpbInJlYWQiXSwiZW1haWwiOiJhZGpvbmVzK2Nsb3VkZm91bmRyeUBnbWFpbC5jb20iLCJjbGllbnRfYXV0aG9yaXRpZXMiOlsiUk9MRV9VTlRSVVNURUQiXSwiYXVkIjpbImNsb3VkX2NvbnRyb2xsZXJfbmciLCJjbG91ZF9jb250cm9sbGVyIiwicGFzc3dvcmQiXSwidXNlcl9hdXRob3JpdGllcyI6WyJST0xFX1VTRVIiXSwidXNlcl9pZCI6IjFiZGVlZTJjLTYwYTMsnipmZjk2MDhlZTg3MiIsImNsaWVudF9pZCI6InZtYyJ9.qITdjMjJFAJVpPSY23lMAorzbsYYHV0WYOM6HWqpprc"} 2012-08-01 17:40:59,187 [main] DEBUG cloudfoundry.Scripts - Login token bearer eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJleHAiOjEzNDQxOTkwODMsInVzZXJfbmFtZSI6ImFkam9uZXMrY2xvdWRmb3VuZHJ5QGdtYWlsLmNvbSIsInNjb3BlIjpbInJlYWQiXSwiZW1haWwiOiJhZGpvbmVzK2Nsb3VkZm91bmRyeUBnbWFpbCsnip0aG9yaXRpZXMiOlsiUk9MRV9VTlRSVVNURUQiXSwiYXVkIjpbImNsb3VkX2NvbnRyb2xsZXJfbmciLCJjbG91ZF9jb250cm9sbGVyIiwicGFzc3dvcmQiXSwidXNlcl9hdXRob3JpdGllcyI6WyJST0xFX1VTRVIiXSwidXNlcl9pZCI6IjFiZGVlZTJjLTYwYTMtNDhiMsnipNsaWVudF9pZCI6InZtYyJ9.qITdjMjJFAJVpPSY23lMAorzbsYYHV0WYOM6HWqpprc 2012-08-01 17:40:59,187 [main] TRACE cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - Invoking client method getApplication with args [snip] 2012-08-01 17:40:59,443 [main] DEBUG cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - Last Request: {"name":"snip","staging":{"model":"grails","stack":"java"},"uris":["snip.cloudfoundry.com"],"instances":1,"runningInstances":1,"resources":{"memory":1024,"disk":2048,"fds":256},"state":"STARTED","services":["mysql-5ea1951"],"version":"5e3a0edb94078f83c62eddc75223601861dc994f-1","env":[],"meta":{"debug":null,"console":null,"version":45,"created":1343839259}} Building war file | Done creating WAR target/cf-temp-1343839259445.war Updating Application: Checking for available resources: 2012-08-01 17:41:13,294 [main] TRACE cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - Invoking client method uploadApplication with args [snip, /home/ant/Projects/snip/target/cf-temp-1343839259445.war, CfUpdate$1@304ed448] Error: null On 27 July 2012 02:10, burtbeckwith <[hidden email]> wrote: > trace 'grails.plugin.cloudfoundry' > trace 'grails.plugin.cloudsupport' -- ________________________________ ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
|
> Updating Application:
> Checking for available resources: > 2012-08-01 17:41:13,294 [main] TRACE cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - > Invoking client method uploadApplication with args [snip, > /home/ant/Projects/snip/target/cf-temp-1343839259445.war, > CfUpdate$1@304ed448] > > Error: null Please retry with version 1.2.3 of the plugin. I submitted a patch that should result in a more meaningful exception. I discovered that basically these errors were caused by socket exceptions. I also recommend having vmc installed as a backup while we try to work out what the best solution to the socket exceptions is. Cheers, Peter -- Peter Ledbrook Grails Advocate SpringSource - A Division of VMware --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
|
Cheers Peter,
I'll upgrade ASAP On 2 August 2012 09:01, Peter Ledbrook <[hidden email]> wrote: >> Updating Application: >> Checking for available resources: >> 2012-08-01 17:41:13,294 [main] TRACE cloudfoundry.ClientWrapper - >> Invoking client method uploadApplication with args [snip, >> /home/ant/Projects/snip/target/cf-temp-1343839259445.war, >> CfUpdate$1@304ed448] >> >> Error: null > > Please retry with version 1.2.3 of the plugin. I submitted a patch > that should result in a more meaningful exception. I discovered that > basically these errors were caused by socket exceptions. > > I also recommend having vmc installed as a backup while we try to work > out what the best solution to the socket exceptions is. > > Cheers, > > Peter > > -- > Peter Ledbrook > Grails Advocate > SpringSource - A Division of VMware > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: > > http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email > > -- ________________________________ ꜽ . antony jones . http://www.enzy.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe from this list, please visit: http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email |
Re: Deploying to cloud-foundry is still a miserable experience.
|
|
Also add
grails.plugin.cloudfoundry.showStackTrace = true to Config.groovy to make sure it prints all exception stacktraces. Burt
|
«
Return to Grails - user
|
1 view|%1 views
Loading...
| Powered by Nabble | Edit this page |